Potbelly Sandwich Shop added special fall menu items on Sept. 13 that will be available until about the end of the year. I accepted a recent invitation to try the Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese, the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich and the Pumpkin Pie Cookie.
The mac & cheese ($7.05) is super creamy, and the dish is more filling than I thought it would be. The all-natural chicken is juicy, and the right amount of Frank’s RedHot sauce sauce is added to enhance, not overpower, the flavor. Honestly, Potbelly should serve this year-round.
There’s plenty of grilled chicken in the sandwich ($6) so that each bite includes some. The sprinkle of blue cheese crumbles was a nice touch. The Frank’s RedHot sauce is dulled a bit by the buttermilk ranch, so add spicy peppers if you want more heat.
The pumpkin pie cookie ($1.30) has a soft middle with a slightly crunchy exterior. The nutmeg shines through–there is also a note of cinnamon–and I kept longing for some whipped cream to go along with this tasty treat.
In Madison, you can find Potbelly on State Street, in West Towne and just past East Towne.